Setlists featuring Alligator Pie, page 4
1 Jun 2009 - Dave Matthews Band at Beacon Theatre, New York, NY, USA
Main: Funny the Way It Is, Alligator Pie, Spaceman, Cornbread, Seven, Out of My Hands, Why I Am, The Dreaming Tree, You Might Die Trying, Everyday, Sister, So Damn Lucky by Dave Matthews, Squirm, Anyone Seen the Bridge, Ants Marching, #41, Time Bomb, Two Step
Encore: Rye Whiskey by Tex Ritter, Don't Drink the Water, Grey Street
30 May 2009 - Dave Matthews Band at Fenway Park, Boston, MA, USA
Main: Pantala Naga Pampa, Rapunzel, Alligator Pie, Don't Drink the Water, Seven, Gravedigger by Dave Matthews, So Damn Lucky by Dave Matthews, Funny the Way It Is, Dancing Nancies, Why I Am, Spaceman, #41, Rhyme & Reason, Squirm, Crush, Time Bomb, Two Step
Encore: Dirty Water by The Standells, Stay (Wasting Time)